If you're unfamiliar with the phrase, an "Alpha roll" occurs when you physically yank your dog into a submissive posture, such as on its side, and hold it there for a period of time. The idea behind this is to demonstrate to your dog that you're the dominant person in the relationship, so they should submit to you.
Proponents of the approach compare dogs to wolves and argue that in order for a connection to succeed, you have to be the leader, or else your dog will attempt to dominate you.
On the other hand, force-free, science-based training techniques have been shown to be more successful and guarantee that you and your dog will have a far better, healthier connection.
Either way, dogs aren't wolves, and wolves don't Alpha Roll.
Proponents of the approach compare dogs to wolves and argue that in order for a connection to succeed, you have to be the leader, or else your dog will attempt to dominate you.
On the other hand, force-free, science-based training techniques have been shown to be more successful and guarantee that you and your dog will have a far better, healthier connection.
Either way, dogs aren't wolves, and wolves don't Alpha Roll.
The initial research on wolf behavior carried out in the 1940s took place in a captive setting. These were not related wolves, brought together at different points in their lives. Tension resulted from this, and there might have been conflict within the team's hierarchy.
A pack in the wild is typically made up of individuals that are connected to one another; there is typically no hierarchical conflict, and the idea of an "Alpha" is no longer relevant.
Seldom do wolves attempt to subjugate another pack member by pinning them down. More often than not, you may see a group member willingly adopt a passive, subservient posture when there is conflict.
Dogs also exhibit this appeasing behavior by demonstrating that they pose no threat and merely seek to maintain peace. Dogs and wolves do not naturally engage in the Alpha Roll.
Furthermore, it has been demonstrated that dogs behave very differently from their wolf predecessors, so it is inappropriate to apply the same guidelines to all situations.
Why It's Not a Good Idea to Train Using the Alpha Roll
A pack in the wild is typically made up of individuals that are connected to one another; there is typically no hierarchical conflict, and the idea of an "Alpha" is no longer relevant.
Seldom do wolves attempt to subjugate another pack member by pinning them down. More often than not, you may see a group member willingly adopt a passive, subservient posture when there is conflict.
Dogs also exhibit this appeasing behavior by demonstrating that they pose no threat and merely seek to maintain peace. Dogs and wolves do not naturally engage in the Alpha Roll.
Furthermore, it has been demonstrated that dogs behave very differently from their wolf predecessors, so it is inappropriate to apply the same guidelines to all situations.
Why It's Not a Good Idea to Train Using the Alpha Roll
A 2009 study that was published in the Journal of Applied Animal Psychology showed that these unpleasant techniques frequently end up producing more problematic behaviors.
Such harsh and confrontational training techniques may cause a dog to become scared. They frequently become frozen until they no longer perceive any threat, at which point they can become defensive and explode violently. In addition, the methods you are using to train your dog do not promote a trusting relationship.
What other training options are suggested?
1: Using reward-based strategies to teach the dog a different desired behaviour is far more humane and successful.
2: When a dog is told that it must get off the couch, it does not snarl to subjugate you. Your dog is not trying to assert their dominance by growling at you as you try to remove them from the sofa. All they want to do is stay in that comfortable location, and they know that growling will usually get them left alone.
2: When a dog is told that it must get off the couch, it does not snarl to subjugate you. Your dog is not trying to assert their dominance by growling at you as you try to remove them from the sofa. All they want to do is stay in that comfortable location, and they know that growling will usually get them left alone.
3: Invest in a cozy dog bed and give your dog delicious treats each time they visit it if you don't want them on the couch. Additionally, practice the 'off' command, which is based on rewarding your dog each time they respond to a request to get off the sofa.
4: Your dog is most likely just happy to see you if they are jumping up. An additional prevalent misconception is that the dog lunges at you to assert its authority. But the reason your dog is probably jumping up is because it has previously received unintentional reinforcement for doing so. Perhaps this behavior was promoted when your dog was a puppy because it was cute, but now that it is an adult, it is not as loved. Some dogs leap up because it gives them the attention they want, even if it consists of their owner pushing them away all the time.
5: Try training your dog to give an alternate behavior; it will reward you with a nice treat whenever it places all four paws upon the ground. Request that your dog go back to its bed when visitors enter the house, then give it a gift. Make sure that everyone in the family, including guests, follows the same rules. If someone is leaping up, remind them to stop it by turning their back.
6: Teach your dog that houseguests are nothing to be afraid of. It's possible that your dog barked when a stranger entered your house. Your dog will naturally use a growl, which is a common means of communication, to let the person know that they are uncomfortable if they are afraid of strangers. If you respond to this by placing them in an alphabet roll, this may cause them to link strangers with this uneasy gesture, which may increase their fear and their propensity to act aggressively.
7: Teaching your dog that fear is unnecessary is far more beneficial and compassionate. Don't press your dog to interact with visitors. Give them the choice to go to another room or a safe place, like a container. Reward your dog anytime it interacts positively with a guest, such as by moving closer or giving them a quick glance, provided that the guest feels secure enough in the same location. Show your dog that interacting with people is beneficial!
8: You will experience longer-lasting improvements and strengthen your bond with the dog when you teach with these non-force, reward-based techniques.
Related Post: